In Search of a Dissertation Committee: Using a Qualitative.
Question about dissertation committees. Dissertation.. Here's my question. I already have my methodologist and my chair for my dissertation committee. I would kill to have this guy on my committee. Is it appropriate to ask him that during our very first meeting?
Each committee member will have been given a completed copy of the dissertation prior to the defense, and will come prepared to ask questions about the thesis itself and the subject matter. In many schools, master's thesis defenses are restricted to the examinee and the examiners, but doctoral defenses are open to the public.
Committee members and examiners in the last defense will be less inclined to question any sections of the results or research designs. New Ideas Into How to Ask Someone to Serve on Your Dissertation Committee Never Before Revealed.
So my senior committee member did not want my PI to graduate a PhD student in under 5 years because it reflects poorly on their tenure decision. This culminated with that committee member nit-picking every mistake within my dissertation (fair enough, perfection is sort of expected at this level) and telling me, at my defense, that I would be a failure because of those mistakes.
How To Ask Someone To Be On Your Dissertation Committee Make sure they will say yes: Ask your advisor if they think the prof would be a good fit on your committee. Pop the question early: There’s nothing weirder than having a graduate student come to your office and spend five minutes explaining why they have the same intellectual interests as you, seemingly for no reason.
Make sure they will say yes: Ask your advisor if they think the prof would be a good fit on your committee. A lot of the time professors will talk to each other first before you meet, so the new addition to your committee may already know you are coming and has already basically agreed to serve.
Ask your chair about the next steps—sometimes the chair will suggest a meeting with you to go over items that came up. Collect the committee’s hard copies with their notes, if this is the procedure. Or ask them to email you tomorrow their marked-up copies or lists of revisions.